Parshas Kedoshim
Shabbos ranks amongst the most stringently binding laws. The Torah reinforces its gravity by pointing out that Shabbos is not suspended in the face of paramount Mitzvohs such as Respecting Parents and Building the Beis Hamikdosh. Shabbos is mentioned side by side with these two commandments.
“Every person must respect their father and mother and keep my Shabbos for I am Hashem” which the Sages explain: Although I have commanded you to obey your father, if he tells you to violate the Shabbos do not listen to him.
“You should keep my Shabbos, and respect my Holy Places” The Talmud interperts that construction of the Beis Hamikdash does not take priority over Shabbos.
Question
Why does the Torah switch it’s phrasing? Twice the Torah conveys that Shabbos prevails over other laws, however in the context of Respecting Parents, it places Shabbos at the end of the phrase. But when discussing the Beis Hamikdash, it places Shabbos at the begining of the phrase. Why are they presented differently?
Answer
The rationale why Shabbos supersedes Kibbud Av V’aim and Binyan Beis Hamikdash differ, thus explaining the variant recordings.
Shabbos overrides respecting one’s parents in much the same way that honoring fathers takes precedence over mothers. If both parents ask for a glass of water, one brings a glass first to one’s father. The reason is because the mother is committed to arranging the father’s food and drink. Similarly Shabbos takes precedence over obeying one’s parents, as they are committed to protecting the sanctity of Shabbos.
Construction of the Temple does not override Shabbos, for an entirely variant reason. The purpose and goals which the Temple accomplishes are fulfilled by observing the Shabbos. Shabbos can attain the same positive aspects as the Beis Hamikdash, hence we don’t build the Beis Hamikdash on Shabbos since Shabbos is replacement for the Beis Hamikdash.
We can now understand the difference in the Torah’s wording when teaching the superiority of Shabbos. When it come to Respecting Parents, Shabbos takes precedence not because it is more prominent or stricter, in much the same way as honoring father is not more important than honoring mother. Rather Shabbos has priority because one’s parent also has to watch out for the honor of Shabbos. Therefore Kibbud Av V’aim is listed before Shabbos. However when we have a choice between keeping Shabbos or putting up the Temple, Shabbos takes precedence because it replaces the Beis Hamikdash. The Torah prefers Shabbos, for even its passivity achieves the objectives that come with erecting the Beis Hamikdash. Therefore Shabbos is recorded before the Beis Hamikdash.
Lesson
Do we value Shabbos like a Beis Hamidash? Do we lookout that others should keep Shabbos?
Story
Rabbi Eliezer Adler (1866-1949) scion of a distinguished family in Stanislaw, Galicia was the founder of the Jewish Community in Gateshead, England. He was non compromising where religion was concerned.
Upon arrival from Europe he initially moved to Newcastle upon Tyne and when his mother died, he needed a minyan, for this purpose he travelled between Newcastle and Gateshead. The most efficient way was crossing the River Tyne by bridge, for which one had to pay a toll. Young Eliezer crossed the bridge daily to Gateshead for religious services.
Before Shabbos he paid the toll in advance and left additional money for any other Jew that needed to cross on Shabbos. Looking out to enhance the Shabbos observance of others.
One Shabbos a jaunty youth smoking a cigarette tried to cross the bridge. The toll collector demanded his dues, to which the youth replied that Rabbi Adler pays in advance on behalf of the Jews. The non-Jewish toll collector responded “Not for the likes of you – does the Rabbi advance payment”.
Weekly Halachah
A non-Jewish worker should be paid after Shabbos for work he does on Shabbos.